Quantcast

Posts Tagged ‘Chola’

Following the fantastic piece of investigative journalism by the Chasing Aphrodite team, we continue to dig and present data that we feel will be raise pertinent questions.

We are back to Idol wing’s published photos of the missing bronzes from the two temples - Suthamalli and Sripuranthan.

idol_wing

Focus on the two Nataraja bronzes. One from Suthamalli

Suthamalli_natraja

and one from Sripuranthan

idols_foreign(1)_page2_image15
sripuranthan nataraja

It is clear by observing the Prabhavali or the circle of flames surrounding the bronze that the two are very different though the stylisation of the Dancing Lord is almost the same.

Slide1

We have the Nataraja in the National Gallery which is said to “closely resemble” one of these - but which one? Lets study them.

171994
171994_Back

Once again the circle of flames helps us know that this resemblance is to the Sripuranthan bronze and not to the Suthamalli Nataraja.

Slide2

Now as published in the Chasing Aphrodite scoop, new photos have emerged of what appears to be the same bronze in the hand of the smugglers in an apartment in India sometime around 2006.

26fz8
shiva-natraja2

The accused Kapoor’s Art of the Past had published this photo in its Catalogue.

1-m5835

Now, as elaborated many times and also highlighted in the gallery’s defenses - there are hundreds of Nataraja bronzes in South Indian temples and they look very similar. However, to the trained eye it is very easy to spot the differences, credit again goes to the lost wax process wherein each is designed by hand, uniquely in wax before being cast in metal. So even with the hazy photos from the Idol wing / Archives - let us draw your eye to one particular aspect of the bronze. Count the flames in the ring and focus on the third one on his right - right under the uplifted foot

Do you see that part of the flame has broken off. Now let us compare all the images with us.

broken
front_broken
rev_broken

Ironically the Lord seems to point out this if you let your eyes follow his bent lower left hand !!!

Ascertaining this fact must not take a few seconds if only we had a better quality image from the Idol wing / IFP Pondy archives.

So one thing is for sure, we are talking of the Sripuranthan bronze and it has been removed from its base pedestal as well !! The larger question remains as to where is the Suthamalli Nataraja now?

During the course of our Independent investigation, we found another magnificent bronze Nataraja in the Art of Past catalogue of March 2011.

item_8
newer one
newer one closeup face

Once again comparing the Prabhavali - it is not the Suthamalli Nataraja. If so where is this from ? Are there more temples from where these precious treasures have been looted and we are oblivious to it. Who is to search for these answers?

Leave a comment »

The controversy over the identity of the two people in this famed Chola painting probably overshadows the Big Temple Vimana’s Shadowless myth.

the+chola+frescp.jpg

It is true that many great scholars did identify them as to be the Great Emperor and his teacher, but recent arguments do offer considerable evidence that to the contrary. This post is to line up these arguments and present them in a coherent manner as well as offer some possible evidences to the identity of the two.

1. First and foremost: The Emperor waited 15 years before taking on the crown from 969 to 985 CE. The Big temple was completed in 1010 CE, which is known to us from the inscription which states the Emperor donated Gold for making the alloy for the Top Kalasam / Finial on the 275th day of his 25th year of reign. a simple math gives us 985 + 25 to be 1010 CE. The last inscriptions of the Emperor is from his 29th year of reign ie. 1014 CE. So at the time when the paintings were done he must have been in his advanced years and not the strapping youth as seen in this painting.

the+two+people.jpg
digitally+touchedup+gokul.jpg

Further more, inside the same painted gallery of the vestibule in the big temple, we have his portraits in the other panels, showing him as middle aged and with a majestic beard - when he is shown worshiping in Chidambaram standing and seated worshiping the very peruvudayar in tanjore.

RRC+wives+thillai

2. The second important point to notice and to me the post important is the very structure of a royal portraiture. In the two panels where we have the great Emperor, no other person is depicted larger than him, except the Lord ofcourse.

rrc+peruvudayar
RRC+wives+thillai

I think most of the scholars erred maybe because so little was known of the overall smaller panels and we are to thank ASI, Sri. Sriraman Sir, Artist Sri Chandra Sir for the line drawings and Sri Thyagu for the brilliant photography - the two books added invaluable wealth of material to what we know of the famed paintings - One by the Tanjore Tamil University and the more recent one by ASI authored by Sri Sriraman.

3. Now back to the same wall but from a longer perspective. You can see that this is not a central panel ( as compared to the other two portraits of the Emperor where he is at the center of the panel along with the Lord), and there are two more people painted above them and they are proportionally larger than these two.

layout
layout2

Obviously you would not want to paint some other mortal above the Emperor and in a larger size than him.

4. So if these are not the Emperor and his Guru, who can they be. On that subject a very interesting puzzle is the Guru’s sacred thread - if it is that. He is shown wearing it over his right shoulder which is very uncommon and usually practised when one does the funeral rites for the departed.

notrrcnkaruvurar

So there is a possibility that it can be perceived to be the Emperor’s son Rajendra with his Guru on his father’s …But then this is on the outer walls of the Sanctum and very very negligible chance for such a portrayal. It can be argued that it is just a cloth ( though vastra yagnopavithams are in vogue during that period).

the+two+people.jpg

5. If these are not them, who can it depict. There is an interesting sculpture in the Tanjore Palace Museum which bear a remarkable resemblance to the odd couple. They are Narada and Chitrasena.

narada+chitrasena
naradha+chitrasena+closeup.jpg
tanjoreartgallery

Lets try to mix and match

bigtemplemural
Picture1
bigtemplemural-compare
Slide1
Slide2

6. Another possible identification comes from studying the famed Sundarar ascending to heaven panel.

sundarar-stiched

Focus on the top left ( as you view it) of the painting

sundarartop
closeup

A host of celestials have assembled to view the divine spectacle and there is a particular row which we need to analyse.

assembly

Clearer in the line drawing

assembly-linedrawing

These are the Dvadasa Adityas, Ekadasa Rudras

Check the two people who are on the extreme left of them.

sundarar-ascending-painting
linedrawing-sundarar

So, as per above since they form part of the welcome party when Sundarar ascended to the heavens along with Cherman Perumal, an event that happened well before the Emperor’s times - the two cannot be him and Saint Karuvurar.

Images Courtesy: Sri Gokul Seshadri, Sri Thyagu, Sri Sriraman, Sri Chandru and Hindu archives.

Leave a comment »

 Page 5 of 50  « First  ... « 3  4  5  6  7 » ...  Last »